Home

The Case Against breastfeeding

Rebecca Thompson Hitt I just read Hanna Rosin's article called The Case Against Breastfeeding published in The Atlantic and I'm feeling really sad. This is the reality of many mother's experiences and it should not be taken lightly Health Sciences The case against separating breastfeeding mothers and infants during the pandemic In a Q&A, Diane Spatz of Penn Nursing and CHOP discusses why it's safe and beneficial to keep them together, even when the mother tests positive for COVID-19 In the years since, breastfeeding in public has become an increasingly controversial topic, and I've heard many arguments for and against (and participated in several). And in each debate, there seems to be a missing element: the issue of intimacy. For many of us who object to public breast feeding, the issue is not breasts exposed in public Bettina Forbes Here's what Hanna Rosin is missing in The Case Against Breastfeeding: Moms are being urged to breastfeed but set up to fail. Ms. Rosin finds that breastfeeding no longer works in her life and doesn't want to be made to feel guilty about not breastfeeding her third child

The Case Against Breastfeeding - The Consciously Parenting

The case against separating breastfeeding mothers and

She concludes that the case for breast milk is hyperbolic. The majority of studies have demonstrated that there's a relationship between breastfeeding and better health. But whether this.. Next to speak is Hanna Rosin, a breastfeeding (that's right) mother of three who recently wrote an article for the current issue of The Atlantic magazine entitled The case against breastfeeding. Morales prompts Rosin with the statement, You are not anti-breastfeeding but you do talk about the society pressures The Case Against Breast Feeding By gregladen on March 29, 2009. Hanna Rosin paints breast feeding, in a recent item in The Atlantic, as a social requirement for the privileged, a no-exceptions.. The Case Against Breastfeeding. Posted Mar 17, 2009. You are reading page 12 of The Case Against Breastfeeding. The current push against co-sleeping in the US is co-sponsored by...wait for it... the Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association, which is full of companies that manufacture cribs The case against breast-feeding: How many IQ points does breast-feeing really buy you? The Atlantic magazine just published an article written by Hanna Rosin questioning the general perception that research strongly supports that breast-feeding is better than formula

The Case Against Breastfeeding in Public from GoFatherhoodÂ

There is no legitimate case against breastfeeding in a broad sense, as much as there is a case FOR conscientious and sound parenting-----the title really grabs the attention and gets the mindset rolling in a negative direction from the start The case against breastfeeding(?) My dear friend Ruchi passed along this article about breastfeeding to me and wanted to hear what I had to say about it. The main thesis of the article is that despite the claims of breastfeeding advocates such as the American Academy of Pediatrics, parenting know-it-all Dr. Sears, and La Leche League, the. The case against breastfeeding In her Atlantic article, The Case Against Breastfeeding, well-known writer Hanna Rosin says, In certain overachieving circles, breast-feeding is no longer a choice - it's a no-exceptions requirement, the ultimate badge of responsible parenting

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act now prohibits employers from firing, harassing, or retaliating against workers for breastfeeding or pumping at work. However it cannot be reliably counted on to provide accommodation rights when workers need them most. Many states have filled in the gaps left by federal law The Case Against Breast-Feeding March 16, 2009 1:21 PM Subscribe Hanna Rosin has written a piece for the Atlantic claiming that the actual health benefits of breast-feeding are surprisingly thin, far thinner than most popular literature indicates The Case Against Separating Breastfeeding Mothers and Infants During the Pandemic In a Q&A, Penn Nursing's Diane Spatz, PhD , Professor of Perinatal Nursing and the Helen M. Shearer Term Professor of Nutrition in the Department of Family and Community Health , discusses why it's safe and beneficial to keep them together, even when the. A Father's Case Against Breast-Feeding It may be the healthiest choice for a baby...but not necessarily for sleep-deprived parents

However, in this article, The Case against Breast-Feeding, she sounds mostly angry and it seems as if she is trying to alleviate her guilt. She attempts to claim that breast-feeding is not necessary, and yet she doesn't even seem to convince herself In a piece entitled A Father's Case Against Breastfeeding in The Atlantic, dad Chris Kornelis argues that rather than encourage breastfeeding, as a society we should encourage what's healthy for the family as a whole. And the thing we should encourage? Formula, if that means mom and dad getting longer stints of sleep

Case Against Breastfeeding Overlooks Big Dirty Secret

Breastfeeding has been documented to exert more effective protection against a spectrum of pneumonia-causing viruses, including influenza, RSV and parainfluenza, in girls than in boys ; these findings were interpreted by the researchers as a nature-provided advantage for survival of females, in order to preserve the species I was pointed to an article in the April 2009 issue of The Atlantic, The Case Against Breastfeeding.Hannah Rosin is a mother of 3 (and, to read the article, an ex-compatriot of mine) who dutifully nursed her first two children until they were a year old, as per the AAP's recommendation In her article The Case Against Breastfeeding in The Atlantic, Hanna Rosin attacks breastfeeding from both a scientific and feminist perspective. I plan to respond to both of them, but the scientific one will take more research and I may only get to it next month (Here it is: The Scientific Benefits of Breastfeeding).However, the feminist one is much easier to address The Case Against Breast-Feeding II. Pediatricians have been scrutinizing breast milk since the late 1800s. But the public didn't pay much attention until an international scandal in the '70s over killer baby bottles.. Studies in South America and Africa showed that babies who were fed formula instead of breast milk were more likely to. A mother's case against a father's case against breastfeeding Yesterday I came across this article written by a father against breastfeeding . And I got pissed off because it was just so, so wrong

The Case Against Breastfeeding - Feminist Philosopher

When I first read Hanna Rosin's article The Case Against Breastfeeding in the April 2009 issue of the Atlantic, I walked away thinking she was just making excuses to justify her decision to not give her baby the best possible nourishment she could. In less charitable moments of reflection on the article, I thought she was weak. Weak. Weak. Weak The case started with an earlier complaint to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, which said the airline prohibited women from pumping breast milk on planes. You Care DENVER — A federal court yesterday denied Frontier Airlines' request to dismiss a lawsuit filed by four flight attendants who allege the company discriminates against pregnant and breastfeeding employees. The court's action allows the proposed class action lawsuit, which is a companion to a related case filed by four Frontier pilots, to move forward

Another Look at the Case Against Breastfeeding • Marie

Another case before the Vermont HRC made clear that this provision does not require that breastfeeding mothers cover themselves or their babies when nursing in a place of public accommodation. After the incident, Gillette filed a complaint with the Vermont Human Rights Commission, the state agency charged with implementing the state's civil. The lawsuit against Mitra QSR, the fourth-largest U.S. KFC franchisee, said that the woman suffered gender discrimination and harassment and that her employer made pumping so difficult for her.

Blacktating: The Case Against Breastfeedin

  1. ding its members that every women has the right to bottle feed and that the choice should be suppported and respected. It was an implicit acknowledgement of just how harmful promotion efforts like the Baby.
  2. ation case against KFC franchisee. Maddy Lauria. there is a limit on compensatory and punitive damages against employers. For even the.
  3. g state law protecting a woman's right to breastfeed and had no policy against breastfeeding
  4. The Case Against Reasoning. . It seems absolutely inevitable, that'll I'll have to post about The Case Against Breastfeeding. The Rosin article is like dog poo - smelly, sticky, but it will not go away, no matter how hard you wipe it with paper towels. Once it's in the fur, only a complete hosedown in hot water and shampoo will suffice, with.
  5. or health benefits, others found none or.
  6. Most People Have Bias Against Breastfeeding Mothers. Parenting. Published Sep 13, 2011. By . And nobody had to be seen breastfeeding for this to be the case, either. In all three studies, the breastfeeding was mentioned, but not done in front of the person being tested

Most health organizations advocate breastfeeding and, with the right support, many women find that they can breastfeed successfully. However, it can also be challenging. Learn about the pros and. The case of a New Hampshire woman who claims she was fired from her job over breastfeeding remains dismissed, following a split decision Friday by the state's Supreme Court. For years, Kate.

Female Middle-Class Angst in The Case Against Breast-Feeding. Hanna Rosin's article in The Atlantic has raised a furor among breastfeeding advocates. I read her article and was amused and delighted with her writing. But unimpressed with her understanding regarding the science of human milk. The article, while quoting studies on human milk. I have rehearsed my objections to the breast-feeding cult at great length in the past, in my Atlantic story, The Case Against Breast-Feeding, and more broadly against attachment parenting in. Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) and Breastfeeding. This interim guidance is intended for healthcare providers and lactation specialists who care for breastfeeding people and their infants and children who receive breast milk feeds during the COVID-19 pandemic. This guidance is intended to inform healthcare providers about the diagnosis. Custody and breastfeeding. If the parents can't agree on custody arrangements, the courts will have to be involved. And if the court feels breastfeeding is being used as an obstacle to a father's access they may see weaning or pumping as the solution. A court probably won't value breastfeeding above a father's time with his child

There are benefits to breastfeeding, of course. These include a small protective effect against colds and diarrheal illness across the population of all infants in their first year When it comes to feeding the newborn, human milk is, from an evolutionary perspective, the biological norm, the time-tested standard of care. The health benefits to the infant of breast-feeding have been amply documented; numerous studies strongly indicate significantly decreased risks of infection, allergy, asthma, arthritis, diabetes, obesity, cardiovascular disease, and various cancers in. Federal court allows ACLU pregnancy discrimination case to move forward alleging the company discriminated against pregnant and breastfeeding employees. Frontier Airlines had requested the. View This Abstract Online; Motherhood and inequality: a commentary on Hanna Rosin's The Case Against Breastfeeding. J Hum Lact. 2009; 25(3):266-8 (ISSN: 0890-3344). Hausman B The homicide case against a breastfeeding mom whose baby died after drugs were found in his system can move forward, a Pennsylvania judge has ruled. Samantha Jones, 30, has been charged with one.

Case Against Grihalakshmi and Gilu Joseph for Breastfeeding Cover. The case has been registered under Sections 3 and 4 of the Indecent Representation of Women Act, 1986 And they in this case truly means everyone — from major medical organizations to overzealous strangers who scold moms for buying formula. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends exclusive breastfeeding — which means only breast milk and any necessary medicines and supplements, no other liquids or foods — for the first six months of a baby's life Uncertainty and lack of knowledge often lead to proscribing against breastfeeding out of fear, which then deprives the infant of the potential protective, nutritional, and emotional benefits of breastfeeding exactly at the time when they are most needed (see the discussion of immunologic benefits of human milk in Chapter 5). Clinical case. Aim: To assess the possible protective effect of exclusive breastfeeding against first-time febrile urinary tract infection (UTI) in children. Methods: Two children's hospitals and local child health centres in the Göteborg area, Sweden, participated in a prospective case-control study. In total, 200 consecutive cases (89M, 111F), aged 0-6y, presenting with first-time febrile UTI were enrolled Background: Some epidemiological studies have shown a protective effect of breastfeeding against type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM), whereas others have found opposite results. The role of early exposure to cow's milk protein and shorter duration of breastfeeding are still controversial. This study aimed to compare the frequency and duration of breastfeeding among siblings with and without T1DM

My case against Hanna Rosin's case against breastfeedin

  1. dset added insult to injury after his wife struggled to nurse their son. Betsy really wanted to breastfeed. She tried. Really hard
  2. g the fetus or infant.In the case of COVID-19 vaccines, the.
  3. It debunked the breast is better mantra that I kept hearing: Breastfeeding might be no more beneficial than bottle-feeding for 10 of 11 long-term health and wellbeing outcomes in children.
  4. ation, breastfeeding does not have to be the do
  5. For pregnant or breastfeeding people seeking information, SOGC offers answers to COVID-19 vaccine Frequently Asked Questions, a detailed statement about vaccination in pregnancy and other resources
  6. ates against pregnant and breastfeeding employees

Analyzing 2.7 million births in 84 developing countries over the past 45 years, the scientists found that the link between breastfeeding duration and average duration of postpartum amenorrhoea. The case against infant-formula-feeding is compelling for those who are environmentally aware of the degradation of the planet. Pile up those empty cans, plastic bottles, and various containers of artificial baby milks in our landfills. Add those bottles and plastic nipples and pacifiers to the mix, and let's see how fast they degrade

The Case Against Mother And Infant Separation Amid COVID19 Pandemic April 27, 2020 Sera Ansardi 3 comments With so much still unknown about how the novel coronavirus spreads from person to person, many establishments have begun exercising extreme caution and practicing strict social distancing in an attempt to reduce the risk of transmission If breastfeeding doesn't work for you, know your choices to keep your baby fed and healthy. Medical experts warn against both choices. Here are some reasons why. That's not the case. Breastfeeding for any amount of time, even just a few days, is linked to lower blood pressure in children at age 3, according to a new study in the Journal of the American Heart Association

objectively against the likely impact it might have on the business. Employers should be careful not to discriminate against breastfeeding employees. See p9 in 'Frequently asked questions' example 2. Tip - It is good employment practice for the employer to keep a short note of any request and the decision you reached with the employee Series: The case against Donald Trump starting with Giuliani. The presidency of Donald Trump has badly damaged the United States. This was evident in the current and ongoing 2021 Gaza Crisis. America in the context of global trust is more of a problem than a solution or reliable partner. Even its own people do not trust America The Case Against Breast-Feeding In certain overachieving circles, breast-feeding is no longer a choice—it's a no-exceptions requirement, the ultimate badge of responsible parenting. Yet the actual health benefits of breast-feeding are surprisingly thin, far thinner than most popular literature indicates An interesting presentation of some of these challenges as well as a rebuttal of some of the claims made in this and other articles extoling the benefits of breastfeeding are mentioned in an Atlantic Monthly opinion piece titled, The Case Against Breastfeeding. Nevertheless, by the end of the article, the author and mother of three who.

We found a couple of interesting links in our inbox today that we thought we'd share with you. First came an April 2009 Atlantic magazine article headlined The Case Against Breast-Feeding, with. Citizens Against Breast-Feeding. P.O. Box 55741. Phoenix, AZ 85078. New York Office: (212) 330-7675. Origins: If pranksters such as Joey Skaggs have taught as anything, it should be for us to be. Bockoras' case is one of a growing number of lactation discrimination lawsuits highlighting the need for more accommodation and acceptance for nursing mothers in the workplace, advocates say The prohibition against Breastfeeding harassment supplements the prohibition against Breastfeeding discrimination and provides clear protection to Breastfeeding women. If a person engages in unwelcome conduct that would be considered by a reasonable person, having regard to all circumstances, to offend, humiliate or intimidate a Breastfeeding. Breastfeeding a baby involves spiritual pollution, contamination and manipulation. The Bible says, your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost. The moment a strange child is feeding on your breast, it therefore symbolizes fire on the mountain. The fire on the mountain implies serious problems between you and your husband or boyfriend as the case.

The backlash against breastfeeding Breastfeeding The

  1. The case will be considered on March 16 for further hearing. This comes a day after the Malayalam magazine's cover, which was a campaign for open breastfeeding, sparked major outrage on social.
  2. Transgender men and women, and non-binary and genderqueer individuals, are physiologically capable of breast or chestfeeding, even if they have had previous chest surgery or have never given birth. It is equally important to note that some trans people experience severe gender dysphoria when breast or chestfeeding, and that they may decide not to nurse their babies for mental health reasons
  3. The New Hampshire Supreme Court is split 2-2 over a woman's nearly nine-year battle to challenge her firing from the state Department of Health and Human Services over breastfeeding

The breastfeeding vs formula-feeding debate is a contentious one. And while the discussion wasn't always considered a hot-button issue, the consensus on what was best varied throughout much of. [update 12-10-19]Two companion cases were filed on behalf of a class of pilots and flight attendants who assert that Frontier's treatment of employees who are pregnant or breastfeeding violated state and federal laws against sex discrimination in employment because they treat pregnancy and breastfeeding less favorably than other medical conditions or disabilities and have

Woman's claim of firing over breastfeeding remains dismissed. CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — The New Hampshire Supreme Court was split 2-2 Friday over a woman's nearly nine-year battle to challenge her firing from the state Department of Health and Human Services over breastfeeding, meaning a lower court's decision to dismiss her case stands Even if you have a breast infection like mastitis, you should continue breastfeeding. In fact, in the case of mastitis, the breast pain and related nipple soreness could worsen if you stop breastfeeding or pumping. Likewise, in the case of thrush, it's best to continue breastfeeding unless your healthcare provider advises otherwise

Breastfeeding controversy: Case filed against magazine, model. The case has been posted for hearing on March 16 Breastfeeding mothers A business cannot discriminate against mothers who are breastfeeding a child of any age. The Equality Act 2010 has speciically clariied that it is unlawful for a business to discriminate against a woman because she is breastfeeding a child. A business may ask a breastfeeding woman to leav The Code makes it against the law to discriminate against someone or to harass them because of sex, including pregnancy and breastfeeding. There is also protection, based on family status, for being in a parent and child relationship. This includes adopting a child. The ground of marital status is also covered This story is not an argument against breastfeeding. My party line, after reading a lot of the research and speaking to a number of experts, is that breastfeeding is truly wonderful if you can.

the case against breastfeeding Nursing Birt

The case of a New Hampshire woman who claims she was fired over breastfeeding remains dismissed, following a split decision Friday by the state's Supreme Court. first filed a lawsuit against. For breastfeeding, CDC's Division of Nutrition, Physical Activity, and Obesity tracks: National and state-level breastfeeding rates. Maternity care practices at hospitals. Public opinion about breastfeeding. Breastfeeding and infant feeding practices. Data, Trends, and Maps. Interactive database with national and state data on eight. According to a survey in the United Kingdom, up to 81% of mothers initiated breastfeeding at birth; however, the rate dropped to 42% by six months, and 71% of breastfeeding mothers reported a.

When FDA approved the first statin in 1987, the medicine came with our strongest warning recommending against use during pregnancy and breastfeeding. This was based on several factors This study explores the relationship between armed conflict and breastfeeding practices of Iraqi mothers. To date, the relationship between violent conflict and breastfeeding is surprisingly understudied. Especially in the Middle East, which is conflict-prone and has a young population, research on war and household behavior is critical for promoting recovery and sustainable development A New York Times' article on the scandal said one Jamaican family's income averaged only $7 a week, leading the mother to dilute the water with as much as three times the recommended amount of. 4 Exposed: Discrimination Against Breastfeeding Workers Despite the medical consensus that breastfeeding reduces major health risks to both babies and mothers, discrimination against breastfeeding workers often forces them to stop breastfeeding or lose their jobs. Lactation discrimination cases from the last decade expose Lowers risk for other conditions: Breastfeeding potentially protects against conditions like asthma and allergies, diabetes, and obesity. Good for you Helps with recovery: It can help your uterus.

The Case Against Breast Feeding ScienceBlog

ARTICLE Protective effect of breastfeeding against childhood leukemia in Zhejiang Province, P. R. China: a retrospective case-control study Zhen Gao a, Rui Wang , Zhao-Xia Qina, Ao Dongb and Chong-Bin Liuc aDepartment of Nursing, Medical College of Nursing, Huzhou University, Huzhou, People's Republic of China; bMedical Test, Clinical Laboratory, Children's Hospital of Zhejiang University. Breastfeeding not only provides the optimum source of nutrients for the neonate and its first strong shield against infection but also lays the foundation for somatic and psychological bonding between the mother and child. During the current COVID-19 pandemic, although the guidelines of the relevant international and national agencies recommend breastfeeding by SARS-CoV-2-infected mothers. Breastfeeding up to 12 months is strongly protective against the more aggressive luminal B, but not against the less aggressive luminal A breast cancer in premenopausal White women. Introduction Breast cancer is the leading cause of cancer death among women worldwide ( Siegel et al., 2015 )

The Case Against Breastfeeding - Page 12 - Ob/Gyn Nursing

Case reports have identified potential AEs associated with fluoxetine during breastfeeding, including fussiness, drowsiness, and impaired infant weight gain. 5 For this reason and because of the higher concentrations in infant serum, it is often recommended that an antidepressant with less excretion into the milk compartment be used when feasible Breastfeeding mothers should get vaccinated against Covid-19 without hesitation: Top ICMR official Influenza, commonly known as flu, was a pandemic 100 years ago but today it is endemic. Similarly, in the case of COVID-19, we expect that it will gradually become endemic from its current state of being a pandemic. Addressing concerns. Breastfeeding worker sues hospital over chemo case. Anne Oulton had just returned to work at Brigham and Women's Hospital after a maternity leave when she was assigned to a surgery that required. The evidence suggests that breastfeeding may have a small protective effect on the prevalence of obesity. In spite of the evidence of publication bias, a protective effect of breastfeeding was still observed among the larger studies (>1500 participants),.. This effect seems to be more important against obesity than against overweight The Case Against Circumcision. Western countries have no tradition of circumcision. In antiquity, the expansion of the Greek and Roman Empires brought westerners into contact with the peoples of the Middle East, some of whom marked their children with circumcision and other sexual mutilations. To protect these children, the Greeks and Romans.

Similarly, in case of COVID-19, we expect that it will gradually become endemic from its current state of being a pandemic. Currently, we recommend the elderly to take annual flu shots A meta-analysis involving data from 20 countries concluded that breastfeeding did not protect against wheezing (due to allergy or otherwise) in affluent countries such as the U.S. Investigators did find that breastfeeding was associated with less wheezing among children in nonaffluent countries, but this was only the case for wheezing that was. Exclusive breast-feeding is not normally associated with any risk, even in the case of maternal infection (online Supplemental Table 1). The main hazards of breast-feeding are exposure to the maternal viral pathogens HIV and human T-cell lymphotropic virus-1 (HTLV-1)

Antibody Therapeutics - ITR Laboratories Canada Inc

Study shows a robust immune response to COVID-19 vaccine in breastfeeding health workers. A recent study by researchers from Poland, published in the journal Vaccines, shows how levels of IgA and. When vaccinated, the body produces copies of the spike protein, which alone does not cause disease, and the immune system learns to react defensively, producing an immune response against SARS-CoV-2 Breastfeeding in public: the need-to-know legal stuff. In England and Wales, your right to breastfeed in public is covered by The Equality Act 2010 which states, A business cannot discriminate against mothers who are breastfeeding a child of any age. This means Breastfeeding is the optimal source of infant nutrition and has been linked to positive health outcomes in early childhood and into adulthood [1,2,3].In Western, high-income Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries, however, breastfeeding initiation ranges from 44% to 99% [] This wide range raises questions about what enables or constrains breastfeeding in. A Case Against Hanna Rosin: Breastfeeding's Risks and Benefits. Women across the blogosphere have responded to Hanna Rosin in droves, but I haven't seen some of my thoughts, so I am posting them here. I agree with Rosin that people such as Dr. William Sears hype breastfeeding out of proportion to its proven benefits. However, that doesn't.

The case against breast-feeding: How many IQ points does

The recommend that infants initiate breastfeeding within the first hour of birth and should be exclusively breastfed for the first six months of their lives. This means that they shouldn't be given any other foods or liquids, including water. This is because breast milk protects your baby against infections, allergies, diseases, and even. The best thing to do is to use a nipple shield and apply nipple cream on the fissure, which can act as a shield against bacteria. It's also recommended to drink a specialized anti-inflammation tea. Nipple thrush. in which case you'd need to stop breastfeeding or pumping (at least for a little while). Talk to your doctor or lactation consultant Tramadol: tramadol and its active metabolite O-desmethyltramadol are excreted into breast milk. There have been case reports of respiratory depression and death associated with the use of this medication. The FDA issued a statement in April 2017 warning against taking tramadol while breastfeeding

COVID-19 Updates: These vaccines cannot protect you fromPregnant Brisbane transgender man launches legal case toRajiv Gandhi National University of Law organised